Saturday, March 19, 2011

What will the .xxx domain mean?

In June or July of this year, a new internet domain will emerge - .xxx There are many sides to this debates and its effect on the culture.

I think it might be a good step, but that remains to be seen.

Some of the benefits:
- xxx sites will be contained in a single area, which makes them easy to exclude or block. schools, and people who do not want to go to these sites can simply set their computers to not show xxx domain names

- the sites will be regulated to disallow some of the worst filth on the Internet, such as child pornography.

However, I think the most benefit could be achieved if xxx was the exclusive area for pornographic material. As it is right now, porn sites can set up shop as a .com, .net, .org, .ca, etc. There is really no limit, and thus there is no protection. However, if xxx sites limited themselves to ONLY .xxx, it would be much easier to navigate away from this societal ill.

Some people say that the xxx legitimizes lewd websites. The issue I have with this argument is that the Internet is already inundated with porn, and it lures in victims each day. I doubt the xxx will make it any more prevalent than if they did not create such a domain.

Some people in the porn industry are against this change, believing it will force them into a corner. Obviously a vital part of the porn industry's strategy is to appear mainstream and to be accessible from anywhere. That's what Hugh Hefner did when he invented Playboy. It wanted to make sure it didn't come across as sleaze, but he wanted it to seem respectable. Often, he pictured high-class individuals. He wanted people to believe that viewing pornographic was somehow chic.

If people in the porn industry are against this, it is probably a good thing.

Others are concerned this will amount to censorship. Again, I ask: So what? Society already practices censorship in many ways. Porn is not allowed in schools or public libraries. Consumers should be at least able to clearly know what they are getting involved with and this in no way characterizes censorship. One comment I read the man was scoffing at the idea of "obscenity". I've heard this before. Basically the argument is obscenity is just a matter of personal preference, therefore nothing can be considered obscene because it's just subjective.

This is just a convenient argument to allow filth to be targeted at anyone, anywhere.

If this whole thing is done in the right way, I think it can be beneficial. It can help people make better decisions by disallowing a bombardment of porn at every turn. The xxx domain will serve as a warning sign for no morally upright person to enter.

Only time will tell the effect.

1 comment:

  1. I think this is a great step for the internet. Having an .xxx domain allows for consent of the viewer to know what they will be viewing and certainly aids schools, parents and work places from allowing those sites to display on their computers.
    I do not think this censors the pornography industry anymore than cybersitters or filtering software currently does and would certainly make them more efficient.

    I can see see this will be a programming nightmare for the people who operate websites with explicit content who will have to update all their linked information in the vast webs of interconnected sites. Anyone with website design experience can understand the frustration of sifting through html code to make changes. So I can see complaints certainly arising from that angle as that sets these businesses back months just to change domains and get up and running again if required to move to .xxx domains exclusively.

    ReplyDelete